Fancy Pies

Ordered two traditional fruit pies and they were delicious. Shared at small family birthday and everyone loved it!

We ordered one Blemon Meringue and one Coconut Key Lime pie, and they were both delicious!

Ordering online was simple and pickup was easy (although unconventional) and seamless.

Blemon Meringue: the lemon curd is nice and tart and the blueberry compote and meringue add some sweetness. Really, really good.

Coconut Key Lime: Also nice and tart, with a hint of bitterness from (I assume) the lime zest. It's a really good balance, and the coconut in the pie crust is a really nice touch.

Although there aren't a whole lot of reviews, I would highly recommend Fancy Pies if you're looking for excellent pies while support local businesses!

I ordered the key lime pie and chai pumpkin pie just a few minutes ago. It looked so good that I had to at least try the key lime pie when I got home. Holy cannoli! I’m usually not a big fan of crust but the key lime crust was the best I’ve ever had. #we eat crusts now and appreciate them. Wow! The filling had the perfect balance of sweet and tart. Definitely the best pie in the valley and tempted to order more for after the Holidays 👀 So happy to find a good place to order pies from and support our small business owners at the same time. Thank you for all that you do! 😊

I was so delighted with the pies I tried from Fancy Pies. They were delicious. I can't wait to order more for the Holidays to share with friends and family!

The name says it all: fancy pies. The presentation was a dream! You could taste the high-quality ingredients and the fresh tasting "just squeezed lemon". The hint of blue meringue peaks were compliments from the blueberry compote that deepens the flavor of the lemon curd.
The delicious, sweet, crust melts in your mouth.
The Blemon Meringue pie is so packed with flavor it may send you into temporary shock. Get ready to (literally) lick your plate clean!