Mermaid Pies and Sandwiches

Was able to get me a car due to high demand. Great staff.
Bonus I had no electricity at home due to Hurricane. I asked if I could use their electric and they let me charge my phone. I was blessed.

Justin was such a nice guy, you can tell he’s extremely passionate about his product and RIGHTFULLY SO!!! I’m always on the hunt for a perfect lobster roll and this place nailed it. Big chunks of the most amazing lobster, lightly dressed on a perfect butter toasted roll. YOU MUST TRY THIS PLACE! definitely don’t skip out on the pie either - key lime was probably the best i’ve ever had, the coconut cream pie was also killer, you can tell they just really care and it shows

EVERYTHING we get at Mermaid Pies when visiting AMI is special. No matter where else we go, Mermaid always exceeds our expectations. I am pretty sure everything is made from scratch daily. I would reccomend something but it is all very, very good. Super friendly family owned and operated........ I mean, even the pickles are awesome! Must stop by when in the area.

Hands down the most delicious and flavorful pies we’ve ever tasted! So far we’ve bought the peanut butter truffle, coconut cream, Dutch apple, and key lime- and they are all amazing! Run to this special shop and see for yourself- you will not be disappointed. Great friendly service and homemade deliciousness. We will be back!!!

Somehow just found this place and I’ve lived down the road for years! Super friendly! The lobster rolls and Cubans are AMAZING. You can order oysters by the box 24 hours in advance. Needless to say I’ll be back at least once a week for the rest of my life.

Absolutely love this place! One of the best lobster rolls we've had. Great portions and very fresh lobster.