Tony Boloney’s Pier Village

They are cooking the slices too long the first time. Too much char on some slices for a NY/NJ slice. The Buffalo chicken slice was very good. Customer service just ok.

This pizza is phenomenal! I make sure to go at least once a week. Ahmad does an excellent job with cooking & customer service!!! You guys rock

Tony Baloney's has been on my personal "Outrageous Famous Foods Bucket List" for some time. I would have prefered to try them for the first time in their OG location in Hoboken but when the opportunity to visit in Long Branch came up, I couldn't resist.
Tony Baloney's claim to fame is the Taco, Taco, Taco pizza - a pizza topped with literally an entire Taco Tuesday menu. 😆 Gauc and three soft tacos -chicken, pork and beef. We were able to get one huge slice to share. It was good and I'm glad I tried it but I wish it was fresher and hotter.
The staff were great. Restaurant could have been cleaner. It obviously gets very busy due to it's proximity to the beach and boardwalk. Plus it's a teenager hang out which isn't always ideal. Would definitely go again though, especially in Hoboken or Atlantic City.

I was a little overwhelmed by all the creative and yummy sounding pizza creations here.....the taco pizza looks amazing. But I wound up getting a plain slice just to see....and it was so good! Their sauce is a little sweet which I love and very rich tasting and the cheese good too. Overall a 9/10