Scarborough Fair Restaurant

On 12/16/23, we went back with our daughter's family for a holiday, all gluten-free dinner for someone with an allergy. The decorations were all up, and the restaurant looked fabulous. Our waitress Electra took good care of us all night, and we ordered drinks and shared the gluten-free crabcake and calamari in addition to wedge salads. All were delicious. For dinner, we got four different gluten-free entrees: NY strip, Filet Mignon, Duroc Pirk Chop, and the Rack of Lamb. Everyone enjoyed their dinner, and there were no allergic reactions. Excellent!
Dessert was a rich chocolate flour lesson cake and Cappucinos. Overall the service and atmosphere were excellent and we will definitely dine there again.

On 11/2/23 We dined at SFR for the first time, and we were pleasantly surprised. Nice old farm house with add-on offered many interesting places to sit. We opted for low seating in the bar area where we could see the piano player.
Nice wine selection by the glass. Soon after being seated, hot rolls and butter were served. For an appetizer, we tried the Steak Bites, which we cooked perfectly, and came with a tasty horseradish sauce.
For dinner, we both ordered seafood, my wife the scallops, and I got the Mariscada, clams, callimari, and shrimp on pasta with a lighter pesto sauce. Next time, I would ask for some garlic to be added to the Mariscada. My wife said the scallops were perfect.
For dessert, we opted for the pumpkin cheesecake and Cappucinos. All we delicious. Overall, we were very pleased and will plan to visit again soon.

This is an elegant fine dining restaurant. There is a large seating area near the bar, a more secluded room known as the Octagon, and private tables along the stairway known as "stair seating", which must be specifically reserved in advance. We ate in the Octagon room, which was very nice, but will request stair seating next time we return.

Food and service were outstanding. Very accommodating and everything was prepared just as we requested. Delicious salad, wonderful halibut and mahi mahi entrees, and yummy flourless chocolate cake for dessert. There is a nice wine list from which we chose a Pinot Grigio.

There is a large parking lot, and also outside seating.

This is is not an inexpensive restaurant, but it has charm and ambience, nice menu selections, and very attentive service. Definitely a place for a special occasion or romantic dinner. We plan to return the next time we are in the area on vacation. One of the nicest dining experiences we had on our recent vacation.

Enjoyed a great meal everything was very flavorful and cooked just the way we liked. Only thing that was off was the food didn't come out hot it was warm. I like my food piping hot.

What a wonderful little gem with delicious food. This is one of those times where I wish the Google review system had 4.5 or 4.75 starts. It was almost a flawless Mother’s Day brunch. This was our first time at this restaurant and I must say the atmosphere is very chic, romantic and not over the top. Our waitress was friendly and very much on top of her game when it came to adjustments that were requested by my girls. We will definitely be back for a romantic dinner.