Schlesinger's Steak House

• Monica Solis
  
  
  (December 6, 2018, 11:47 pm)

  I love going there for dinner but...we went tonight and I ordered a fillet mignon, medium and my husband got a different steak med rare. Mine started off good all around the ends but the middle which was pretty much the whole steak was super rare! Even the waiter agreed. The waiter was great and the cook offered to cook it more but we were in a hurry and didn't have time. So I only ate around it which was a few bites. I don't know how hard it is to cook a steak but it was so rare I don't think he was paying attention and sent it out anyways. We will definitely be back but I won't be in a hurry the next time in case I have to send it back. Not happy this time :(

• david dobuzinsky
  
  
  (December 6, 2018, 8:15 pm)

  Service from Raymond was great. The pickels and breads were good for starters. We had such a nice time Tuesday evening celebrating a birthday for Andrew , son number 2. The steaks were all delicious. The french onion soup was good , not too salty. I had the special ,chicken soup it was delicious, with some spice I never had before. One dish was shrimp stuffed with crab, that we gave an okay. If you want a great steak this is the place to go.

• Renee Pastore
  
  
  (November 18, 2018, 12:20 pm)

  Came here last night for my Birthday, nice quaint setting, I had shrimp cocktail, my husband had the potato skins & crab cakes for appetizers, for dinner, I had the Prime Rib, baked potato, my husband had the Schlesinger's steak, steak fries, OMG both pieces of meat were PERFECTLY cooked, our waitress was SUPER sweet, definitely coming back, thank you for the desert for my Birthday, really made dinner more special

• Taylor Scott
  
  
  (September 18, 2018, 11:26 am)

  Schlesinger's is definitely a unique experience. It has an associated cigar bar which I'm not a fan of, but they have a non smoking dining area. The service was good. The house pickles (mild dill flavor) were decent, but the bread was cold and hard. I had a french onion soup that had good developed flavor. The salad had a lot of hearts in it that I'm not a fan of having in a side salad. They also have a small dressing selection. A had a filet and mashed potatoes. Everything was above average just not high end. The steak had a real strong iron taste and potatoes lacked seasoning. Overall it was a good experience, but a step below a Ruth's Chris or similar.

• Eileen Miloff
  
  
  (July 11, 2018, 9:18 pm)

  We have been eating here off and on for years. Food consistently good, service good too. Went there tonight for lobster special and were served a ton of food. Priced right, very enjoyable. Waitress (Tanya?) gave us just the right amount of attention.

Schlesinger's Steak House menu - New Windsor NY 12553 - (845 ...

(845) 561-1762. Dinner; Appetizers. ... Menu for Schlesinger's Steak House provided by Allmenus.com. DISCLAIMER: Information shown may not reflect recent changes ...

Schlesinger's Steak House - New Windsor, New York ...

ToniAnn Ryan Killmer added a new photo — at Schlesinger's Steak House. December 31, 2018 · New Windsor, NY · ToniAnn Ryan Killmer added a new photo — at Schlesinger's Steak House .

Schlesinger's Steak House Restaurant - New Windsor, NY ...

The menu at Schlesinger's Steak House features USDA beef and meals that use only fresh ingredients. ... (845) 561-1762. Created with Sketch. Website ...

Schlesinger's Steak House in New Windsor, NY | Whitepages

View contact info, business hours, full address for Schlesinger's Steak House in New Windsor, NY 845-561-1762. Whitepages is the most trusted online directory. Sign up to gain access to mobile numbers, public records, and more.

Schlesinger's Steak House in New Windsor , NY - YP.com

Get reviews, hours, directions, coupons and more for Schlesinger's Steak House at 475 Temple Hill Rd, New Windsor, NY. Search for other Steak Houses in New Windsor on YP.com. Start your search by typing in the business name below.

Schlesinger's Steak House, New Windsor, Hudson Valley ...

(845) 561-1762. Cuisines. Steak ... Related to Schlesinger's Steak House, New Windsor ... steak house new windsor 1762 zomato, schlesinger's steak house menu ...

Schlesinger's Steak House - New Windsor NY | AAA.com

Learn more about Schlesinger's Steak House or other dining options in New Windsor. ... NY 12553 Phone: (845) 561-1762. Steak. AAA Inspector Rating. 8.7. Guest Rating.

Schlesinger's Steak House, New Windsor - TripAdvisor

Schlesinger's Steak House, New Windsor: See 177 unbiased reviews of Schlesinger's Steak House, rated 4 of 5 on TripAdvisor and ranked #4 of 57 restaurants in New Windsor.

Schlesinger's Steak House - 80 Photos & 108 Reviews ...

Phone number (845) 561-1762 Business website schlesingerssteakhouse.com; ... Yelp users haven't asked any questions yet about Schlesinger's Steak House.