Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington

It was my first time coming into this shop. The smell of sweetness hit me when I walked in, and I was greeted. I wanted to try the Granny Apple pie, but they were sold out, and I decided on Key Lime. Best decision ever, as it was very tasty, and I was damn near licking the container. LOL. The guy at the front was very polite and helpful. I was even able to get my pie 'on the house' as their system was having to be rebooted. Thanks so much! I appreciate you being so kind and hospitable. :)

My first experience walking into Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Arlington were filled with friendly greetings, the man in the front was very helpful since it was my first time coming in. The workers are full of energy that keeps the environment light and inviting! Now to the pies, you can tell that the pies are made with love because I have been back numerous times NEEDED to try a different flavor! 100% MUST TRY! If not, you are missing out!

Just stopped in by to get a little treat and bought the buttermilk pie and chocolate thumbprint cookie and it was pure delight! The pie was so creamy and you can taste the love that was baked into it. The cookie wasn't too sweet and taste the was a real cookie should taste like. And the best part of this place was the team that works there. They were so welcoming and sweet and it felt like they truly appreciate their customers. 10/10 I wish I took a picture of the treat but they were inhaled so quickly they didn't even stand a chance. They place is definitely a hidden gem ♥️

This place is so good. The staff is always so friendly and welcoming. The pies are baked fresh daily. The crust is king. If you get the crust right the filling should come easily. The pecan pie is one of my favorite. The peanut butter pie is creamy and nutty. The coconut meringue pie is decadent. I've always purchased the minis. Just the right amount of yummy. They often have promotional deals and rewards for their repeat customers.

Overall pretty good! Got a four pack minis to see what flavors I liked and I wasn’t disappointed! Favorite is the chocolate cream; least is the buttermilk. The latter was too bland in my opinion. The cookie was fine but it was super dry and it fell apart before I could get a nice pic of it :(