Amico's New York Pizza

This is a family favorite. Their sub sandwiches are stacked high and are large enough to split.. The free garlic bread for the table makes time go quickly and folks you before your served if you're not careful. The sliced pizza can be a bit cold, but the full ones are fresh and made with good ingredients.

Hands down the very best pizza in town. It is truly like pizza by husband used have in NY. It is the most authentic Italian food tucked away in this small strip mall and we have tried most of our favorite things and loved them. Only the best Italian places can make a good egglpant parm and theirs is wonderful! It is small - so look at the crowded and busy times, it is such a typical local Italian restaurant... the wines much like you would expect...basic table wines but pair good with Italian food! Large or actually very large portions so order accordingly and watch out for the garlic bread because it is addicting. Wonderful group of people - staff could not be more friendly - It is just our kind of place and makes my husband feel like he is back in New York... They also do take out and nothing changes with the quality there as well... It is a always on the short list!!!

Our favorite local pizza place. NY style pizza. Love their meatballs too.

Being from New York myself, I had high expectations, and was mostly satisfied. The salad was great, the mozzarella wedges were on point, the pizza was great, and the wait staff excellent... so why only 4 stars??? The dough for the pizza and the complimentary garlic bread was on the sweet side, which is what knocked it down a little for my personal tastes (I would have given 4.5 stars if Google allowed half stars). I did enjoy everything, but really would have absolutely loved it more if the breads didn't have that sweet undertone.