Steinhilber's Restaurant

My wife and I had dinner here for our anniversary yesterday. The weather was so nice that we decided to eat outside on the deck. The deck is huge, and has several large circular shaped tables which include fire pits in the center. The atmosphere was enchanting and romantic. The menu was impressive in choices. As a local; you know the butterfly fried shrimp are a must try 😋. It's just good fried shrimp! In addition to the appetizer shrimp, I had the special fish of the night; which was a baked whole red snapper over vegetables and my wife ordered the halibut and vegetables. We were both delighted with the flavor........the red snapper was light and flaky and the halibut was creamy and savory. We were so full after the feast, that we decided to skip coffee and dessert at the end of the meal. The evening flowed together to create a perfect memory for each of us and we both want to thank our amazing waiter Larry for his humor and professionalism. What a delight!

Great food, just a bit overpriced. Cocktails were good and strong, but also pretty tart. Pomegranate salad was nice. Entrees of butternut squash ravioli, beef Wellington, and side order of half lobster Thermidor were all fantastic, just, like I said, seemed a bit pricey. Bread basket was very nice, don't miss out on it, apparently it's by request only. Lava cake and dessert drink were pretty good, didn't taste any Chambord in the lava cake, but it is still a tasty chocolatey option. Service was just okay, seemed like our waitress maybe had too many tables or just wasn't checking in very often. Definitely worth a visit despite a couple drawbacks, also nice location on the water with lots of outdoor seating. Only place in the area I've seen lobster therm offered and it was very good, worth it for this alone if you haven't had it before.

This would’ve been 5 stars and I would definitely recommend. The food was all around delicious. My halibut was a little dry and they served it with no sauce, because the kitchen was too lazy to make more. The fry mix was excellent as well as the she crab soup and risotto! There were some lack of service we believe she could’ve been new. All around they did the right thing the atmosphere is gorgeous!

This is a very eclectic placej. It's buried in a residential neighborhood. They have great outdoor dining if the weather permits and a very nice back grass area that you can walk around near water. I found the food to be very high quality and the vegetables be from their local garden. The service was on point no issues there. Pricing, check their online menu, it can be a little expensive. With tip it's about $100 per person with drinks. The interior amniance and the price points just don't match up for me. I Think they should spend little bit more effort on the interior getting it to match their high-end menu.

This was our first time visiting Steinhilber's. Service was impeccable!! My husband and I both ordered the fried seafood platters. The portions were large and was absolutely delicious! We also ordered the oysters Rockefeller for our appetizer. If I'm being completely honest it wasn't that good. The oyster pieces were small and there was way too much sauce. Overall we had an excellent experience and will definitely return.